The Enron Collapse: How the 7th Largest U.S. Company Vanished Overnight
Checking your brokerage account and seeing it’s lost 5% of its value is shocking enough, but imagine if it had lost over 99% of its value?
Well, that’s what happened to millions of Enron shareholders in late 2001. Stocks in the corporate giant tumbled from a mighty $90 to mere pennies over just 16 months, causing thousands of heavily-invested people to lose their life savings. Originally an icon of American energy, Enron had shrivelled to nothing in a sea of fraud and corrupt corporate shenanigans.
It’s worth noting that in 2001, Enron wasn’t just a utility company. It was America’s seventh largest corporate entity by revenue, and worth over $70 billion. Considered a genuine “Blue Chip,” ordinary people trusted the firm to keep their life savings safe. What was so remarkable about the Enron episode, therefore, is how the company fooled everyone — Wall Street, employees, regulators, and even members of the board.
Table of Contents
Toggle
- Humble Beginnings
- The House Of Cards Begins To Unravel
- The Grand Unraveling
- The FBI Investigation And Trials
- What Was Learned?
Humble Beginnings
Interestingly, Enron wasn’t always the giant we remember it as today. It actually had far humbler beginnings.
The company formed in 1985 under CEO Ken Lay, following the merger of InterNorth and Houston Natural Gas. The idea was to create an integrated natural gas company, ready for the energy deregulation schemes of the 1990s.
Interestingly, this is when the company pivoted. Instead of putting its resources into physical pipelines and refineries, it switched to trading energy contracts, helping producers and other market participants hedge their risks.
At this time, a consultant who would later go on to become COO, Jeff Skilling, entered the picture. He thought he could give the firm a leg up by changing internal accounting to a “mark-to-market” standard. Going against best practices, the firm would book future profits as real cash flow, even if the money hadn’t yet arrived.
When this happened, Enron’s stock soared. Investors saw the firm was making money hand over fist, and regular families began to see its merit as a reliable, all-American blue chip stock. By the end of the Clinton administration, it seemed like the company was unstoppable. Traders were using Enron’s platform for commodity derivatives in the coal, steel and gas markets, and loving it.
However, all of this growth was phantom. While the top-of-page numbers looked good, Enron was hiding some nasty accounting secrets, and banking on a miracle to save it.
The House Of Cards Begins To Unravel
Skilling’s enabling of the fudging of Enron’s official numbers was bad, but CFO Andrew Fastow’s setting up of special purpose entities (SPEs) was even worse. The financial officer used these as a way to conceal everything the company didn’t want stakeholders to see on its balance sheet.
Officially, the idea was that Enron was “hedging” its bets. But, really, it was just a scheme to hide the true state of the company’s finances from investors and other stakeholders.
Using its mark-to-market accounting, Enron reported an almost impossible $101 billion in revenue in 2000. But, of course, it was mostly fake. Lofty valuations coincided with overcharging for California utilities and bumping up blackout prices, revealing a pattern of corporate greed.
Seeing the writing on the wall, company leaders began selling stock while telling regular rank-and-file staff that everything was fine. Skilling was later found to have sold tens of millions of dollars of Enron shares before the crash.
The Grand Unraveling
Eventually, during the Dot-Com bubble implosion, Enron ran out of financial runway. Shares went from $90 apiece during the summer of 2000 and fell to less than a dollar by the spring of 2001.
During this calamitous period, Skilling quit his job, citing family reasons. Ken Lay returned as CEO, telling the media everything was well, but it was not.
In November 2001, Enron decided to correct its books, restating its earnings back to 1997. This move admitted hundreds of millions in losses and billions in added debt, causing share values to tank. At this time, it also entered failed merger agreements with another energy company, further exposing the issues at the firm.
When all was said and done, Enron filed with officials for bankruptcy with just $63.4 billion in assets. The share price for the firm collapsed over 99% to 26 cents a pop and 20,000 people lost their jobs and pensions.
The FBI Investigation And Trials
Trying to get to the bottom of the catastrophe, the FBI launched one of the largest white-collar investigations in the agency’s history. Its probe went as deep as possible, interviewing thousands of employees and associates of the firm while exploring the misleading earnings and C-level schemes to pump and dump the stock.
Not surprisingly, Skilling was eventually found guilty of fraud and sentenced to 24 years. Ultimately, he served 14 and was released in 2019. Fastow got five years after cooperating with officials.
Overall, courts convicted 22 people for financial crimes associated with the Enron fiasco. Lay was found guilty for his part in the accounting fraud but died before the courts could sentence him. Asset sales managed to raise $21 billion for the victims, but it wasn’t enough to cover their losses.
What Was Learned?
Enron remains one of the most infamous and diabolical stories in corporate history. That a small group of executives could fool so many people for so long is a damning indictment on law enforcement officials, regulators, institutional investors, and Wall Street.
However, it did spark reform. Many commentators view the episode as inspiring the 2002 Sarbanes-Oxley Act, demanding stricter audits for C-level executives and tighter accounting standards. It also revealed the value of whistleblowers, like company employee Sherron Watkins, encouraging more federal-level protection for people who speak out.
Enron remains seared into the corporate psyche of America because of the financial damage it did to the victims. Ambitious, hard-working people lost enormous sums of money because of the greed and avarice of a small few at the top.
Perhaps something similar is occurring today with the current AI and tech bubbles? Maybe, creative accounting is being used once again to pull the wool over the public’s eyes.